— September 11, 2019
The first Google Panda algorithm update was rolled out back in February 2011, affecting roughly 12% of all global search results. The impact was both huge and unprecedented, but Panda was only the first in a long line of major algorithm updates that would change the future of search forever.
Panda marked the beginning of Google’s war against web spam and “black hat” SEO and it remains one of the most notorious updates in the search giant’s history.
However, the role Panda plays in Google’s algorithm has changed in recent years and the general state of web content has evolved too. So now is a good time to reassess Google Panda and consider what it means for SEO in 2019.
What does Google Panda target?
The simple answer is that Google Panda aims to reward quality content and prevent low-quality or deceptive content from showing in the SERPs. Of course, algorithmically measuring the “quality” of content is difficult but, even in 2011, Google managed to pinpoint a number of issues that suggests content shouldn’t rank in high positions:
- Thin content: Pages with very little content or technical issues preventing Google’s bots from seeing content (e.g. hidden content, dynamic content etc).
- Keyword stuffing: Forcing or hiding keywords within content in order to boost search ranking.
- Irrelevant content: Content that doesn’t match the keywords, titles and other elements you’re optimising for.
- Content farms: Websites that publish high volumes of low-quality content, often taking content from elsewhere on the web and compiling it on a domain that offers little original value.
- High ad-to-content ratio: Pages that prioritise ads over content (high ad-to-content ratio, ads above the fold etc).
- Low-quality or excessive user-generated content (UGC): While user-generated content (UGC) in itself isn’t a problem, it needs to be relevant to the topics covered in your domain/pages while adding value to the overall experience.
- Excessive affiliate links: Again, there’s nothing inherently wrong with affiliate links or affiliate websites, but your content must have something to offer besides promotional links.
- Lack of authority: Panda changed the way Google looked at website and page authority – something that has continued to evolve to this day (more on this later).
- Deceptive content: Content designed to deceive users – for example, making ads look like regular content in order to generate more clicks.
- Deceptive links: Links that don’t take users to the promised location.
That’s what Googe Panda was targeting back in 2011, when keyword stuffing, gateway pages and deceptive content were all too common. It’s a testament to algorithm updates like Panda that these issues are less prevalent today and we can now talk about things like relevant content being a basic SEO essential.
What does Google Panda mean in 2019?
With Panda becoming a part of Google’s core algorithm, we no longer see separate updates targeting the specific criteria we looked at in the section above. However, this also means that core algorithm updates (which happen several times per year) may or may not include changes to the way Google targets issues like thin content or the weighting they have in rankings.
This week we released a broad core algorithm update, as we do several times per year. Our guidance about such updates remains the same as in March, as we covered here: https://t.co/uPlEdSLHoX
— Google SearchLiaison (@searchliaison) August 1, 2018
There are two things to keep in mind when it comes to optimising for Google Panda in 2019:
- The same rules apply: Broadly speaking, the same issues Google targeted with its first Panda update are still targeted today. The key difference is these were once common spam or black-hat tactics whereas now, avoiding keyword stuffing, deceptive content etc are basic SEO essentials.
- How Google applies them has changed: As Google’s algorithmic technology has improved, the search engine is more capable of measuring subjective factors like “quality” content and detecting deceptive tactics.
Some SEOs argue Panda is less relevant since being integrated into Google’s core algorithm but recent updates have proven otherwise.
Google Panda and E-A-T
Last year, Google updated its Search Quality Evaluator Guidelines (PDF) which provide instructions for a human team of search quality evaluators. The new guidelines put a heavy emphasis on E-A-T, which stands for expertise, authority and trustworthiness.
Then came the updates.
Since August 2018, we’ve seen a series of core algorithm updates that indicate drastic changes in how Google determines content quality, echoing the new version of its quality guidelines. The impact of these updates was reminiscent of the original Panda and Penguin days and many of the same factors we associate with Panda were targeted:
- Thin content
- Irrelevant content
- Deceptive content
- Inaccurate content
- Deceptive advertising tactics
- Lack of authority
- Excessive or dishonest use of affiliate links
These factors have been targeted by Google’s algorithm for years but the latest wave of updates tell us these factors are even more important now. In the age of fake news, Google wants to see content published by genuine experts – especially when content claims to offer advice on serious issues such as health, finance and law.
Medical websites were hit hardest by the first update in August, which was nicknamed “the Medic Update” as a result. However, affiliate websites, cryptocurrency sites and domains offering legal or financial advice were also hit in subsequent updates.
Core algorithm updates can implement changes to any combination of factors in Google’s main algorithm, but it’s clear that many of the factors Panda first targeted in 2011 are still relevant today. In fact, many of them appear to have more weighting in Google’s core algorithm following the past year of updates.
Technically they’re not called Panda any more, but the same ranking factors are still relevant in 2019 – perhaps more than ever.
Need help with your content?
If you need help ensuring that your website sends positive ‘expertise, authority and trust’ signals to Google, get in touch with our SEO and content experts today on 02392 830281 or drop us an email and we’ll call you.